The Eternally Radical Idea with Greg Lukianoff

The Eternally Radical Idea with Greg Lukianoff

The Status Quo Rebels

‘Breaking the Academic Filibuster’ — Part Three

Greg Lukianoff's avatar
Greg Lukianoff
Nov 18, 2026
∙ Paid

Thank you to everyone who signed up to become paid subscribers to read part 1 and part 2 of Breaking the Academic Filibuster, my book-length argument for why now is the time for higher education reform, how fiercely the higher education establishment will fight to preserve a downward-spiraling status quo, and how we can think big about fixing higher education so it can better help us understand the world as it is.

If you’re already a FIRE member and you’d like to read this series, please write us at greglukianoff@substack.com and we’ll give you access.


Imagine the CEO of McDonald’s writing a book called Why the Fast-Food Business Is Better Than Ever. Would you read it? Probably not. But even if you did, would you take it as a disinterested assessment of the industry? Of course not. The guy running McDonald’s says the fast-food business is doing great. No kidding.

Christopher Eisgruber, the president of Princeton, has written something awfully close to the higher education version: Terms of Respect: How Colleges Get Free Speech Right. His publisher explains that the familiar charges of censorship, indoctrination, and hostility to dissent are “badly misguided.” Eisgruber himself told The Daily Princetonian that American universities are the best they’ve ever been.

This is why we did the Marlboro University thought experiment in the first place. Sure, higher education is a unique industry, but it’s still an industry. As of November 2026, the higher education endowments alone could cover the market price of buying every major publicly traded U.S. soft-drink company (not just Coke, Pepsi, and their competitors, but their subsidiaries and brands, like Frito-Lay, Quaker Oats, and Minute Maid) and every publicly traded U.S. airline, with room left over to cover the annual revenue of the entire global recording industry.

That’s just endowments. It doesn’t get into things like real property, the hundreds of billions in annual revenue that never reaches the endowments, or the nontrivial fact that over a quarter of the U.S. government’s financial assets are student loan notes that exist because of higher education. If you look for another industry to compare higher ed to in terms of its government entanglement, defense and healthcare are the closest rivals: markets dependent on government money that enjoy an enormous amount of regulatory privilege, with occasional flare-ups of political, if often performative, disagreement.

Any industry at that size, no matter how draped in nostalgia, will operate with all the usual self-interest, institutional self-deception, and economic, political, and social incentives to convince the world that everything is going great. However, higher education has one additional superpower: wildly disproportionate influence over what society considers true. That’s quite a home-field advantage when you’re grading your own enormous, too-big-to-fail industry. And of course the president of Princeton has every incentive to tell us that the megabusiness he helps lead is doing just fine.

All this makes it a little less mysterious that, at an Association of American Universities meeting in April 2025, Eisgruber had a remarkably adverse reaction to the suggestion that universities might need reform. According to Rose Horowitch in The Atlantic, Eisgruber, who chairs the AAU, got into a 15-minute confrontation with Vanderbilt chancellor Daniel Diermeier and Washington University chancellor Andrew Martin. The latter two men were arguing that universities had done plenty to bring public distrust on themselves and needed serious reforms. Eisgruber all but accused them of helping Trump undermine American higher education simply by acknowledging that universities had serious problems of their own.

So two university leaders admitted that universities might have earned some of the public’s anger, and Eisgruber treated that as helping Trump. Try reforming an institution when acknowledging the problem is treated as disloyalty.

The fact that a political movement you oppose has noticed an actual problem does not make the problem imaginary. Nor does it give the institution that created it a lifetime exemption from self-criticism. If we ever adopted that rule, practically no institution in America would have to reform itself again.

And then we come back to the Yale report that started this whole adventure. After years of denials and excuses, Yale’s own faculty committee acknowledged that the crisis of trust is real and that universities bear significant responsibility for it. Yale’s committee was willing to look at its own house. Meanwhile, at one of the most prestigious gatherings of university presidents in the country, acknowledging that the house might need repairs had become a political loyalty test.

Princeton versus the data

You can watch the Academic Filibuster in action in Eisgruber’s attack on FIRE’s College Free Speech Rankings. He argues that our rankings too often mistake controversy for censorship, and he suggests that the technical schools near the top may be doing well simply because they don’t have as many politically contentious conversations. Well, first, if one of the complaints about higher education is that some departments have become so ideologically homogeneous that dissent is unusually difficult, “the schools with fewer of those departments have a better speech climate” is not exactly the thunderous rebuttal he seems to think it is.

But here’s the bigger problem. Let’s read this year’s top ten, in order: University of Chicago, Claremont McKenna College, Georgia Tech, Michigan Tech, Vanderbilt, Dartmouth, Purdue, Appalachian State, University of Virginia, and George Mason. Yes, there are two technology-focused schools in the top four. The other eight, however, are a far cry from a network of engineering institutes designed to protect students from the shocking discovery that people disagree about politics. Chicago has humanities departments. Vanderbilt has humanities departments. Dartmouth and UVA have humanities departments. All four have plenty of opportunities for political controversy. They also have something else in common: leaders who have taken free speech seriously enough to make changes. Vanderbilt is fifth. Dartmouth is sixth. UVA is ninth. Not exactly the Polytechnic Institute of Avoiding Difficult Questions.

And how’s Princeton doing? In the 2027 rankings, it finished 176th out of 261 schools, with an F overall and FIRE’s lowest, red-light rating for its written speech policies. Its student-perception results are better on several measures, which is useful information if you’re trying to understand the place rather than win a debate. But written restrictions and what administrators actually do to speakers are part of a speech climate too. Princeton’s president might be forgiven for wanting people to see the encouraging parts of his record, but the rest of the record still exists.

To determine FIRE’s rankings, our research team combines almost 63,000 student survey responses with speech policies and the way universities respond to speech controversies. We publish our methodology, and we’ve improved it after criticism. If someone wants to reweight the factors or propose a different survey, great. Run it. Publish the results. Eisgruber seems far more interested in explaining why our evidence shouldn’t count than in producing a better test.

Ryne Weiss, FIRE’s director of research, took on Eisgruber’s criticisms, including a particularly blatant example of Political Cooties. Eisgruber insinuates that FIRE’s research is suspect because we receive money from conservative foundations, without offering any evidence that donors influenced a single finding. In fact, 74% of FIRE’s funding came from individual donors, with foundations accounting for the remaining 26%. Princeton has conservative donors too. So what? That tells us nothing about the quality of Princeton’s scholarship, just as FIRE’s donors tell us nothing about whether our research is accurate.

Then there’s the database. Eisgruber wrote that FIRE had changed its Disinvitation Database into a Campus Deplatforming Database without adequately explaining why. We had published an explanation in February 2024. We added campaigns against performances, films, and art exhibits because expression extends beyond people standing at lecterns. You can disagree with that choice. You could even offer a competing definition and compare the outcomes. What you can’t do, at least not very persuasively, is complain that the explanation doesn’t exist when it’s sitting on our website.

And then he pointed to a Princeton heckler’s veto from 1970 that isn’t in our database, which covers incidents since FIRE was founded in 1999. We had to pick a cutoff date, and we thought “the organization exists” was a pretty reasonable limitation for expectations on our tracking ability. But if you know any fourth-dimensional beings who want a job in research, please contact me. (We’ve discussed that incident elsewhere on our website since, in a discussion of deplatforming attempts from the last century.) The other problem with treating 1970 as Princeton’s last gasp of illiberalism is that Princeton had two disrupted events in April 2025 alone; one, a shoutdown of a national security consultant, and the other, pulling a fire alarm and singing during an event with a former Israeli prime minister.

Eisgruber also objects to counting campaigns to disinvite speakers. Of course students have the right to demand that a speaker be canceled. But whether those campaigns succeed or fail, they tell us something important about the campus speech climate. A campus where students routinely try to silence people they disagree with has a free-speech problem, even when administrators refuse to give in.

Eisgruber’s attempt to explain away self-censorship as good manners is especially frustrating given what we actually know. In FIRE’s 2024 survey, 40% of conservative students reported frequent self-censoring in class, compared with 21% of liberals. And North Dakota State University’s researchers found that 79% of liberal students thought professors should be reported for offensive comments. They even tested what students considered reportable: 22% of all students would report a professor for saying there are two biological sexes, and 20% for arguing against affirmative action. You’d think a university could tolerate an argument about affirmative action without someone reporting the professor. What on earth does any of this have to do with good manners?

Ryne also points out that Eisgruber dismisses students’ growing acceptance of shutting down speech by invoking the tired “falsely shouting fire in a crowded theater” cliché. We’ve knocked that one down again and again, including in a great video featuring FIRE Legal Director Will Creeley.

The more important thing here is that, in our most recent survey, 69% of students nationwide say shoutdowns can be acceptable at least rarely, 50% say the same about blocking audiences from entering a disfavored speech, and 30% about using violence to stop speech they dislike. At Princeton, those numbers are 66%, 52%, and 24%, respectively. If those numbers don’t alarm the president of Princeton, I don’t know what would.

Eisgruber holds up a University of North Carolina system study as supposedly more objective than FIRE’s research. One problem: FIRE researcher Sean Stevens helped design it, its findings are consistent with ours, and six of the seven UNC campuses in our rankings have reached the top 20, thanks in large part to policy reforms made with FIRE’s help. Apparently our research becomes respectable when somebody else uses it.

Ryne had a simple suggestion: Princeton should conduct its own survey, using whatever questions Eisgruber prefers, and publish the results. Please do. I’d love to see them.

Eisgruber also dusts off the old William F. Buckley argument: critics cherry-pick a few outrageous campus anecdotes to make universities look radical. That might have worked decades ago. Today we have speech codes, court decisions, disciplinary letters, national surveys, and universities documenting their own abuses. We even have Yale admitting that much of the criticism was right. The evidence has changed even if the excuses haven’t.

Eisgruber is hardly alone, either. At the very top of higher education, we keep hearing variations of “Nothing to see here,” even as the problems become painfully obvious to people outside the industry. Former Penn board chair Scott Bok called the years before Liz Magill’s resignation a “golden age for elite higher education” and said Penn wasn’t looking for a reformer. Former Columbia president Lee Bollinger treats much of the criticism as old-fashioned populist hostility to progressive values. Wesleyan’s Michael Roth responded to Yale’s acknowledgment of serious problems by warning that its proposed reforms would make things worse. Others insist there’s “no crisis of trust” or dismiss public concern as a “moral panic.”

The message: Our institutions are doing fine. It’s everyone else who needs to get a grip.

I get the appeal. We’ve all encountered parents who cannot accept that their adorable child might have started the fight. Not my handsome son! Now imagine that the child is a multibillion-dollar university with an endowment, consultants, public-relations staff, lobbyists, and thousands of people whose livelihoods and social status depend on believing in its excellence. Of course there’s a market for books reassuring these people that things are better than ever. And plenty of the affection for these institutions is genuine. Professors really can change lives, and universities really do produce extraordinary scholarship. But they also have jobs, budgets, prestige, and political territory to defend. And unlike most industries, they have enormous influence over what the rest of us are taught to believe is true.

What’s most perverse about this is that some of the loudest defenders of the downward-spiral status quo insist that they’re fighting for academic freedom. Their favorite target is often the person who documents an abuse, rather than the university that committed it.

Let’s look at two revealing examples of people defending the establishment while somehow imagining themselves as the brave resistance.

User's avatar

Continue reading this post for free, courtesy of Greg Lukianoff.

Or purchase a paid subscription.
© 2026 Greg Lukianoff · Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start your SubstackGet the app
Substack is the home for writing, podcasting, and media founders.